US Police: "We Understand the Intention, But It's Illegal" ? Issued a Warning
In Korea, Failure to Maintain Headlights Is Subject to Penalty
The story of an American driver who drove with a flashlight inserted in place of a broken headlight has sparked controversy online. On December 30, Yonhap News TV, citing the local Wisconsin media outlet Green Bay Press-Gazette, reported that a driver who replaced a damaged headlight with a flashlight has become a hot topic among American internet users. On December 12, local police in Wisconsin stopped a speeding vehicle on the evening of December 5.
However, there was a more serious issue than speeding. Upon inspecting the vehicle, the police found that one of the headlights was broken and a flashlight had been inserted in its place. The driver had attached the flashlight as a temporary measure to secure visibility while driving at night. In response, the police stated, "While we understand the driver's intention to improve visibility, a flashlight is not a legally approved device for vehicle headlights." The driver was fined only for speeding and received a warning, rather than a penalty, for using the flashlight.
"A Clever Response" vs "Clearly Illegal"
When the authorities released this information on social media, it sparked heated debate among local internet users. Those defending the driver responded positively, saying, "It's better than doing nothing at all when driving at night," and "A clever response for safety." Some even joked, "It's like a real-life MacGyver." On the other hand, there were critical opinions as well. Comments included, "No matter how good the intention, illegal is illegal," "If the flashlight falls out while driving, it could lead to a secondary accident," and "There are concerns that this bad example might spread." In response, the police emphasized, "Headlights are a crucial safety device for nighttime visibility and for making your vehicle visible to other drivers," and added, "They should not be replaced with temporary devices."
"Maintenance Comes Before Improvisation"
The situation is no different domestically. According to Article 37 of the current Road Traffic Act and the Motor Vehicle Management Act, vehicles operating with lighting devices that do not meet standards or are damaged are subject to enforcement as poorly maintained vehicles. Driving with a broken headlight can result in a fine and an order for repairs. In fact, there are ongoing cases in Korea where drivers are caught operating vehicles at night without functioning headlights, tail lights, or brake lights. The police repeatedly urge drivers to check their vehicles before departure, stressing that "a headlight malfunction is not just a minor inconvenience but a major accident risk factor." Experts warn that makeshift solutions can actually lead to even greater danger.
The situation is no different domestically. According to Article 37 of the current Road Traffic Act and the Motor Vehicle Management Act, vehicles operating with lighting devices that do not meet standards or are damaged are subject to enforcement as poorly maintained vehicles. The photo is not related to the specific content of the article. Pixabay
Above all, non-standard equipment like flashlights have weak mounting, and their light angle and intensity do not meet vehicle standards, potentially obstructing the vision of other drivers. Ultimately, the best choice for safety is not an improvised fix, but immediate repair. Since even a small malfunction can lead to a major accident, it is essential to check vehicle lighting devices regularly.
© The Asia Business Daily(www.asiae.co.kr). All rights reserved.
