Death from Acute Pneumonia After Staying at UK Accommodation
Facility: "We Conducted Inspections" vs Family: "Negligent Management"
An incident in which a British woman died after using a hot tub during a family trip to celebrate her 70th birthday has sparked controversy over possible negligence in facility management.
According to reports from The Sun and other foreign media, on February 7, 2020, Paulette Crooks, aged 70, visited the Tuppence Farm holiday cottage on the Isle of Wight with a group of ten family members, including her daughters. She died after using the hot tub at the accommodation.
After returning home from the trip, Crooks complained of dizziness, vomiting, and other systemic symptoms. On February 16, she was admitted to a hospital. Despite intensive care, she was diagnosed with Legionnaires' disease, and her condition worsened, requiring mechanical ventilation and an induced coma. Ultimately, she died on March 8 after suffering a stroke and myocardial infarction.
The bereaved family claimed that poor hygiene management of the hot tub led to the infection and held the facility responsible. From the day of arrival, Crooks’ family used the hot tub at the accommodation several times. Her daughters testified that “the tub had a musty smell, the water gradually became cloudy, and even turned green.”
The manager insisted that daily inspections were conducted and said, “If there had been a problem, it would have been reported.” However, the family countered, stating, “Not a single inspection was carried out during our stay.”
Subsequent on-site investigations by the environmental health team did not detect a clear positive result in the specific hot tub, but water quality issues were found in another hot tub on the same premises. However, the local authorities eventually concluded that prosecution was not possible. The coroner explained to the jury that “the key issues are whether the infection occurred at the site and how it contributed to the death.”
Legionnaires' disease is an acute pneumonia contracted by inhaling contaminated steam or water droplets. The bacteria thrive particularly well in environments where warm water accumulates, such as hot tubs and showers. The incubation period is usually 2 to 10 days. Early symptoms resemble a cold, such as mild fever, fatigue, and muscle aches, but the disease can quickly progress to high fever, chills, cough, difficulty breathing, and pneumonia with chest pain.
The World Health Organization (WHO) and health authorities in various countries have stated that regular disinfection, maintaining high water temperatures, and preventing water stagnation are key to preventing Legionnaires' disease. In particular, spas and hot tubs are structurally classified as high-risk facilities and require strict management.
© The Asia Business Daily(www.asiae.co.kr). All rights reserved.
