"Three 'Perfectly Timed' Pregnancies: Chinese Woman Avoids Serving a Single Day of 3.5-Year Prison Sentence"

The photo is for illustrative purposes only and is unrelated to the article content. Pexels

A woman in China was sentenced to three years and six months in prison, but managed to avoid spending even a single day behind bars by repeatedly becoming pregnant and giving birth at precisely the right moments, three times in total.

On October 14, China Newsweek reported that "Sun, a woman living in Zhenjiang, Jiangsu Province, was sentenced to prison for criminal offenses, but has sparked major public controversy after it was revealed that she avoided incarceration by timing her pregnancies and childbirths perfectly on three separate occasions."

According to the report, Sun was sentenced to three years and six months in prison in February 2023 for issuing false tax invoices and embezzlement. However, since the case was first filed in 2021, her repeated pregnancies have led to her detention and sentence execution being continuously postponed. Chinese criminal procedure law stipulates that "female offenders sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment or detention may serve their sentence outside prison for humanitarian reasons if they are pregnant or breastfeeding a child they have given birth to." While this regulation was originally intended for humanitarian purposes, recent cases of "pregnancy being exploited as a means to evade sentence execution" have fueled controversy.

Three 'Perfectly Timed' Pregnancies

According to publicly available case records, Sun, born in 1987, worked as a financial manager at a company. She was arrested in September 2021 on suspicion of embezzlement, but was released on bail because she was pregnant. She was later sentenced in February 2023 to three years and six months in prison and fined 400,000 yuan (about 80 million won). Her accomplice in the same case, Zhu, was sentenced to eight years in prison and fined 4.8 million yuan (960 million won). However, while Zhu began serving her sentence, Sun did not go to prison. The reason was, once again, that she was either pregnant or breastfeeding.

The timeline is as follows:

▲September 2021: Released due to first pregnancy → Gave birth in December, breastfeeding period until December 2022

▲January 2023: Pregnant again → Gave birth in October, breastfeeding period until October 2024

▲Late September 2024: Submitted new pregnancy diagnosis just before end of breastfeeding period → Third pregnancy

▲May 27, 2025: Gave birth to third child (father's name left blank on birth certificate, child takes mother's surname)

As a result, it is calculated that Sun is unlikely to be incarcerated before May 2026. Zhu's family has protested, calling this "maliciously planned pregnancies." The court only stated, "The decision was made in accordance with the law."

Image unrelated to the article. Pixabay

Institutional Loopholes and Legal Dilemmas

Legal professionals note that "most women who are pregnant or breastfeeding are permitted to serve their sentences outside of prison." However, concerns are growing that this system, if abused, could undermine the fairness of the criminal justice system. Currently, Chinese law does not provide a clear definition of "malicious pregnancy." The key issue is to prevent those serving sentences from using pregnancy as a means to evade punishment.

A Chinese criminologist told the media, "Pregnancy is largely a physiological and accidental factor, so the term 'intentional pregnancy' is legally inadequate." He added, "The key is to comprehensively assess whether there is recidivism or violation of correctional regulations, and decisions about incarceration should not be made solely based on the number of pregnancies." He also emphasized, "The rights and interests of the fetus and mother should take precedence over the authority of the law, and serving a sentence outside prison is not an exemption but an extension for humanitarian reasons."

Cases of Abuse... Frequent Fake Pregnancy Incidents

Recently, in Shanxi Province, China, prosecutors launched an investigation after discovering that Chen, who had been sentenced to five years in prison for fraud, repeatedly became pregnant and gave birth over four years to avoid incarceration. Chen was sentenced to five years in prison for fraud in December 2020, but was allowed to serve her sentence under house arrest instead of being incarcerated, due to her pregnancy. Over the past four years, she avoided prison by becoming pregnant and giving birth three times with one man. However, authorities became suspicious of her actions and began an investigation, which found no evidence of child-rearing at her home. There were no signs of three children being raised in Chen's house, and the third child's household registration had been transferred to her ex-husband's older sister.

Chen was already divorced, with her first and second children being raised by her ex-husband and the third child having been given up for adoption. Prosecutors determined that Chen had exploited pregnancy and childbirth as a means to evade sentence execution and immediately decided to reincarcerate her. However, considering that her remaining sentence was less than one year, she was ordered to serve the rest of her term in a detention center rather than a prison. She is currently serving the remainder of her sentence in a detention center as ordered by the court.